Call

Can I Be Compensated For Pre-Existing Conditions After a Car Accident?

Yes, Texas law lets you recover compensation when a car accident makes an old injury or condition worse, even though it existed before the collision. Insurance adjusters often use a prior diagnosis to justify a lower offer, but a documented change in your pain or mobility tells a different story.

At Abraham, Watkins, Nichols, Agosto, Aziz & Stogner, our Houston car accident lawyers see this situation frequently: someone with a manageable back condition gets rear-ended, and their symptoms become significantly worse. Texas law generally offers more protection in these cases than insurance adjusters acknowledge.

A free consultation with Abraham Watkins costs nothing to start, and our team will walk through your medical history and what changed after the crash. Call 713-222-7211 or contact our firm online and bring any records you already have.

What Are Pre-Existing Conditions?

A pre-existing condition is any injury, illness, or diagnosis you had before the collision, whether healed, treated, or quietly present. None of these blocks you from recovering money for what the accident added on top, and conditions that come up often include:

  • old back or neck injuries;
  • arthritis or degenerative disc disease;
  • prior surgeries on the same joint or spine;
  • chronic pain conditions such as fibromyalgia; and
  • diabetes or other conditions that slow healing.

Documenting these conditions doesn’t hurt your claim; it protects it. Insurance companies see similar patterns after a car accident or truck accident, and the real question is what changed in your body after the crash.

What Is the Eggshell Plaintiff Doctrine in Texas?

What Is the Eggshell Plaintiff Doctrine in Texas?The eggshell plaintiff doctrine means a driver who hits you takes you as you are, fragile spots included, not as a hypothetical healthy person. A driver who hits someone with no prior condition might only cause soreness that heals on its own; a driver who hits someone with a fragile spot doesn’t get a discount just because the harm turned out worse.

However, if an old injury turns into a herniated disc, Texas law still holds the driver responsible under decades of settled case law rather than a single statute, a rule Houston car accident lawyers often rely on.

How Can a Pre-Existing Condition Affect Your Car Accident Claim?

A pre-existing condition affects a claim by giving the insurer an argument that your pain came from the old injury, not the new collision. That argument weakens once your records are separated before and after, and adjusters commonly raise a few objections:

  • your symptoms existed before the collision;
  • your treatment history shows a gap before the accident;
  • your condition would have worsened on its own; and
  • your current pain matches an old diagnosis, not a new injury.

These objections turn a straightforward claim into one of the more contested insurance disputes on the table, especially when the insurer never examined you. A clear, chronological medical record usually answers each objection before it becomes a real problem.

What Does Aggravation Mean Under Texas Law?

Aggravation means the accident made an existing condition measurably worse, whether through more frequent pain, a new need for surgery, or a permanent loss of function. Texas law treats this worsening as a compensable injury on its own, and doctors often chart it as an acute exacerbation.

How Much Compensation Can You Recover for an Aggravated Condition?

You can recover compensation for the economic and non-economic losses tied to how the crash changed your condition, not the condition itself. Under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 41.0105, medical expense recovery is limited to amounts actually paid or incurred, and compensation here commonly includes:

  • additional medical treatment made necessary by the collision;
  • pain and suffering tied to the worsened symptoms;
  • lost wages during extra recovery time; and
  • reduced earning capacity if the aggravation becomes permanent.

Proving aggravation doesn’t require a perfect medical history, just proof that the wreck made things worse. Whether the case involves a standard car accident or a multi-vehicle pileup, we see this pattern regularly enough to know which records matter most.

How Do You Prove the Car Accident Worsened Your Condition?

Proving aggravation comes down to comparing your medical records from before the crash with everything documented afterward, ideally through the same specialist or imaging type. A treating physician’s written opinion carries more weight than a general complaint of pain. Strong evidence usually includes:

  • medical records from before the collision showing your baseline condition;
  • imaging or test results taken shortly after the wreck;
  • the responding officer’s crash report;
  • a written opinion from your treating physician; and
  • a consistent treatment history without unexplained gaps.

Under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 16.003, you generally have two years from the collision date to file suit, so gathering records sooner keeps options open. If a fair settlement never materializes, these disputes are typically litigated in the Harris County civil district courts.

Why Choose Abraham Watkins for a Pre-Existing Condition Claim

At Abraham Watkins, we spend real time separating your old medical history from what the crash actually changed, since that distinction decides whether an insurer pays fairly or lowballs your claim. We work directly with treating physicians to document that difference in terms an adjuster cannot easily dismiss. A generic demand letter rarely holds up without that groundwork.

Pre-Existing Condition Claim FAQ

Do You Have to Tell the Insurance Company About Your Prior Injury?

Yes, honesty about your medical history protects your claim more than hiding it does, since insurers routinely obtain past records anyway. Leaving out a prior injury only gives the adjuster a reason to question your credibility.

What If Your Doctor Says the Condition Was Already Getting Worse?

A doctor’s note about a gradual decline does not erase your claim; it means your case needs to isolate the sudden jump in symptoms after the collision. Comparing appointment notes from before and after usually shows this jump clearly.

What If the Crash Happened While You Were Working?

An accident on the clock can create a workplace car accident claim that runs alongside your case against the other driver, and the two do not cancel out. Whether you can pursue both at once usually depends on whether your employer carries workers’ compensation coverage and whether you were performing job duties at the time of the crash.

Houston Car Accident Lawyers Ready to Review Your Claim

A pre-existing condition should never be the reason an insurance company pays you less than your crash is worth. Our attorneys at Abraham Watkins have built a reputation on separating old injuries from new damage in these disputes, and we bring that same attention to detail to every claim we handle.

A free consultation is available now to walk through what your medical history means for your claim. Call 713-222-7211 or contact our firm online for a clear answer about your next steps.

Contact Us
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Untitled
Testimonials
Houston personal injury attorney

Request A
Free Consultation

Fields Marked With An “*” Are Required

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Untitled